“Manipulative and Mis-informed”
(Review written for 'Talking Points: Transgender (ebook)')
The author spend most of the pages promoting idea of "body over soul" and comparing racism, species confusion to transgenderism. The author confused between transgenderism and LGB, he attempted to mis-inform the reader. In chapter 2, the author put the blame on technology development. He uses a very bad example of racism, equates it with species confusion, and brought the topic further to transgenderism. This is a tactic trying to create confusion among readers who are unfamiliar with the topic. The author only started to discuss about the Bible in chapter 3. The author further suggest on what the reader should do. Therefore, this book is not a thought provoking book, but a manual according to what he believe as "what the Bible says". Lastly, the author expressed about his concern that his freedom of speech are pretty much suppressed. However, this phenomena happened on both sides, pro-LGBT Christians were suppressed in most of the chruches and in most of the circumstances too. It was a great dissapointment that the author only mentioned about the Eunuchs once in his book. This is clear that the author doesn't give a fair discussion and biblical information to the reader on the great debate of transgenderism and the Bible. As a conclusion, this is not a helpful book for Christian, but a manupulative book.
Thanks for your review. Sorry that you found the book less than helpful. We don’t make any apologies that this is a book by a Christian minister, written primarily for Christian people—with the aim of helping Christian believers apply their faith and worldview to this complex and heartfelt question. As we say in the introduction “Transgender" covers so many different expressions that it is impossible to speak precisely and carefully to each person’s experience—if you have been upset or hurt by any of the ways we expressed the things we have tried to communicate in this book, we apologise.
But we do not want to apologise for any of the convictions we have shared in the book about who we are as created and fallen people, and how we are called to grow and be when we are redeemed through Christ for eternity. We also share your desire to help Christians understand more about the pain, difficulty and confusion that many transgender people experience, and a need for churches to love and welcome those who find themselves in this place. Wherever you are in your own journey, we hope you find a group of Christians who will care for you as a human being who will share with you the good news that sets everyone free. With our love and prayers. The Good Book Company Team